Medical School vs. Nursing School: What the Hours Are Really Like
Dr. Robin: Welcome back to I Want to Be a Doctor or Something. I'm Dr. Robin. I'm here with my friend Jill, a registered nurse.
Jill: Hi, friends.
Dr. Robin: We're two healthcare besties sharing the real, wild, and funny side of medicine for anyone who's thought about a career in healthcare. Ready? Let's go.
Dr. Robin: So, Jill, you're up today. What do you want to talk about?
Jill: Yeah, so I was wondering: when you first started as a doctor, did you ever do anything really embarrassing regarding a patient, orders, or things like that? Because I sure did.
Dr. Robin: Well, what happened to you?
Jill: Oh my goodness. I was in a patient's room and absolutely loved the patient. She was so sweet, and I had my manager in the room with me because she was kind of checking to make sure I was doing everything according to protocol. I'd just started working on my own and had just gotten my license.
Jill: She had a G-tube, which, for people who don't know, is a feeding tube that goes into your stomach. You can put medicines and tube feedings through it. She had some GI issues, but I checked to make sure it was placed correctly. Then I took out the residual, which you're supposed to do before giving medication or feedings, to make sure the pH is within normal limits.
Jill: I tested the pH, took out all the residual, and put it into the canister beside me. You're supposed to measure it—that part was correct. But then, while my manager had turned around to do something in the patient's room, I took it to the bathroom and dumped it in the toilet.
Dr. Robin: So what were you supposed to do with it? I've never done this. Doctors don't do this stuff.
Jill: Well, it is in the nursing Bible that you always put it back in the patient, but that's something I missed in nursing school. I didn't know that it could possibly affect the total pH in the patient's intestinal system. She was fine; nothing happened. Of course, I never, ever did it again. But my manager was like, "What are you doing?" And I'm carrying this to the bathroom and flushing it.
Jill: So I learned my lesson not to ever do that again, but it was very embarrassing. What about you?
Dr. Robin: That'd be very memorable. See, I wouldn't know what to do with it because doctors don't do this stuff, so I'd have no idea. We throw up, and I know that can mess up people's electrolyte levels and things like that, so it makes sense, but I still would never have known.
Dr. Robin: I think that's the whole thing, right? We have totally different training. I have no idea how to do most of what you do. There are so many things where I'm like, "Let me get your nurse." And they're like, "Well, aren't you a doctor? Can't you do it?" Nope. I have no idea. I don't touch machines. I don't touch IVs. I don't touch them; I'll get in trouble with the nurse. I don't touch it.
Jill: That's okay. I don't do surgeries either, so it's balanced.
Dr. Robin: Yeah, we balance each other out. But I had never really thought about it being like throwing up. You're right. Worst-case scenario, I guess she could have ended up in metabolic alkalosis or something like that. But she ended up okay. That's basically what it is.
Jill: Just remember, if you're going into nursing and you're taking care of G-tubes, always put it back. Don't toss it.
Dr. Robin: That's good to know. I hadn't even thought about putting it back. That's really interesting. It wouldn't have occurred to me. So I just learned something today.
Dr. Robin: As a brand-new doctor, I was so terrified of hurting someone. And I think we have the benefit of all those years of medical school. So, for nursing school, how many clinical hours do you have before you actually start?
Jill: Well, you have clinicals each semester. I did my associate's degree first, but it's a few hours—like 10 to 15 each semester. Then, at the end, you have about 13 twelve-hour shifts, something like that. So nothing like what you would have in medical school.
Dr. Robin: But it's still a great deal.
Jill: And the thing with nursing is that it's so different because you learn on the job with each patient. You just have to know the basics of how to do everything. Then you go to a heme-onc unit, or GYN, or post-op, and each one has its own protocol. All you have to know going into it is the general stuff. Then you can learn the details for each one. I think it's just so different that way.
Dr. Robin: And I think that's what makes it so flexible, where you can change to different specialties. You can learn because it's all based on the same concepts, I'm assuming.
Jill: It's very similar. Each semester, we go through pediatrics, an OB-GYN rotation, three med-surg courses, and lots of pharmacology and patho. In a way, we're having our subspecialties in nursing school, but it's much more condensed. A lot of the information is really, really deep, as any nursing student out there knows. But putting it into practice, you definitely want to know that big general overview.
Jill: For my BSN, we also had clinicals with that. I can't remember how many shifts, but it was a lot.
Jill: With medical school, you're doing residency and having those long hours, right?
Dr. Robin: Oh, for sure, because there are work-hour restrictions. Everyone knows exactly how much they've worked because it's regulated—or it's supposed to be regulated. You don't report when it isn't, because if your program loses accreditation, then you lose your ability to work. It's a tricky system because you're not going to report your residency program when you need a job someday. It's a really interesting balancing act.
Dr. Robin: When I started my rotations in medical school, we didn't have a work-hour restriction for medical students yet. They had just put one in for residents. The work-hour restriction for residents was 80 hours a week on average, but that's averaged over four weeks. You can't work more than 30 hours in one shift, and you have to have at least one 24-hour period off per week.
Jill: Wow, yeah.
Dr. Robin: The hours are just bonkers. A golden weekend is a two-day weekend. Eventually, doctors generally do get two-day weekends, but everyone knows a golden weekend is a two-day weekend. That's a normal weekend for everyone else, but you'd get one every four to six weeks—an actual weekend.
Dr. Robin: Usually, it was when you were post-call because it would work out. You'd go home after lunch on Friday, get Saturday and Sunday off, and come back Monday morning. It was incredible. You're like, "I had a whole weekend off." People are like, "You mean a long weekend?" And you're like, "No, two days. I left on Friday and didn't come back until Monday." And people are like, "Nice for you, I guess."
Dr. Robin: The first two years of medical school are in the classroom. It's basically a full-time job being in school. My lectures ran from eight in the morning until somewhere between three and six, depending on the day. Then you'd go to lab, and you'd be studying really late, too. It was a full-time job even then. Nobody works when they're in medical school.
Dr. Robin: The second two years are rotations. You might get a cushy one. In my fourth year, I did a breastfeeding rotation. It was the nicest rotation in the whole world. It was two weeks of just checking on moms and helping them. The lactation consultants didn't want to see you later in the day. They'd say, "Why don't you go home and read about it or something?" And I'm like, "Okay, bye." So that was great.
Dr. Robin: But most rotations are 80 to 100 hours a week, and you do 30-hour shifts a lot of the time. Residency schedules vary by place, but for me it was Q3, which meant we were on call every third night.
Dr. Robin: Let's say it was Monday. We'll skip Monday for now. So, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday. On Wednesday night, you'd be there from first thing in the morning. You'd work all day and all night, then the next morning, and go home after lunch on Thursday. You'd get that night to rest. You had to have at least, I think, 10 hours off between shifts. You'd go back Friday. And because it's Q3, it's Friday, Saturday, Sunday, so you're on call again Sunday. You'd go back to work all day Sunday.
Dr. Robin: That's why you only got a golden weekend once in a while, because everything had to line up perfectly. It messed up everyone else's schedule. It was really complicated to schedule.
Jill: Oh, I bet that was so tough. So tell me about the 30-hour shifts, if you don't mind. Do you take a break and nap if you have time?
Dr. Robin: If you have time, yes. There's this myth of white clouds and black clouds. Have you heard that before?
Jill: I haven't, no.
Dr. Robin: Doctors will know exactly what I'm talking about. No one else apparently does. You would not believe how superstitious people are. You'd think we're very highly scientific, right?
Dr. Robin: A white cloud is someone who has nothing bad happen on their shift. They sleep, they can watch movies, they get their meals—everything's good. I was in Victoria's black cloud, so I saw all this crazy stuff you never see, really rare stuff. In the morning, you do morning report with the whole team when everyone comes back, and they'd be like, "You did what? You saw what?" And we were just like, "Yeah."
Dr. Robin: Nights depended on what happened. I'd do admission after admission. Even as an upper level, I wouldn't abandon my interns. I'd still be helping them and very involved in everything.
Jill: That's a lot. Wow. Well, thanks for that insight. I'm just trying to think back to nursing school. We did probably around 300 hours or so of clinicals each semester. The good thing about it—which felt horrible at the time, but after hearing you talk about that—is that they were spread out over a duration of time. They were 12 hours, and sometimes at work we would do up to 16 hours and things like that. But I never had to do 30-hour shifts.
Jill: If there are any nurses watching who have had to do a 30-hour shift, let me know. That's really tough.
Jill: I'm assuming it's illegal.
Dr. Robin: That's what I was thinking.
Jill: I know in my state, up to 16 hours is legal, which I've always thought, "How is that legal?" You're so fried by the end of the shift. But 30? I'm pretty sure that's probably not legal.
Jill: Yeah, there are very few people who are outside the law. I guess doctors are one of them, where they're like, "Yeah, they're fine."
Dr. Robin: Well, the thing is, you adjust to it. I wake up and my brain is just on. I don't do that gradual wake-up thing I vaguely remember from before. I'm instantly on. I can answer the phone and answer questions, which is annoying. Whenever we've had some 2 a.m. text or something like that, or I get a text in the middle of the night, people are like, "How is she always on like this?"
Dr. Robin: It's because if I get up to pee—which sometimes you have to do—my brain's like, "Oh, good morning. Time to..." And I'm like, "No, no, no. Sleep."
Dr. Robin: The other thing is I'm really good at just going to sleep. When you work those crazy hours, you learn that you've got this much time. The saying is: if you're standing, sit down; if you're sitting down, lie down; if you're lying down, go to sleep.
Jill: Wow, so you kind of trained your brain for that. That's really good insight for anyone who's thinking about pursuing medical school. Each state is different, I'm sure, and the laws and things like that may be different.
Dr. Robin: That's it, that's a—sorry, I was trying to offer hope.
Dr. Robin: You can check out the programs. There's a program in Utah that's well known in family medicine because they're family-oriented. I think the attendings take night call, so you don't take night call.
Dr. Robin: Instead of our call rooms, we had one call room for the interns, who are the first-years, and one call room for the upper levels. And it was bare. We had an old hospital bed that didn't work, that kind of thing. This residency in Utah was like a mythical residency. People talked about how they had a kitchen, a family room, and sofas, and your family could come hang out with you when you're on call so you didn't have to be away from your family. They didn't have to be away from you.
Jill: That's really great. I wish more places could follow that, because that's important. Even though when you go into the medical field, you pretty much are dedicating your life to a career, especially if you're going to medical school. Nursing is a lot, too, but medical school definitely wins hands down with those hours. If they could start changing and thinking about ways to make it a little more reasonable, that'd be great.
Dr. Robin: I feel like for both women—for nurses, doctors, anyone—it really changes who you are, because you become so focused on someone else's needs and you completely forget yourself. It's obviously very complicated and very medical. There's lots of science, but it's also very basic, like body needs. It's not like flying an airplane. This is keeping someone alive moment to moment. Flying an airplane is important, too, but with this, every breath they take is important. It's a lot.
Jill: It is. And it can be a calling, some people may feel, or it may just be that they really enjoy science and medicine. But if you're going into medical school, just know that you've got some hours ahead of you.
Dr. Robin: You have, you have. And if you don't like those hours, become a nurse, because you do so much good.
Jill: I was going to say, it's still hardcore.
Dr. Robin: You still have to learn all the science, and you're at the bedside more, right? You're in patient care more, but you also get to go home after 12 hours.
Jill: Yeah, yeah, yeah. We get to do that. So that is much more fortunate. There's still kind of a shortage of nurses where I'm at, so we encourage anyone who's thinking about nursing to go into nursing school for sure.
Dr. Robin: There's a shortage here, too. I think there's a shortage everywhere. You have a guaranteed job where I am. I know someone who graduated and got a $5,000 bonus when she signed up because the hospitals were competing for anyone.
Jill: So, yeah. Wow, yeah.
Dr. Robin: Yeah, it's very needed.
Jill: And maybe you'll get a Dr. Robin to work with, too, because I know she's a really good teacher. You do meet those doctors who are really good to work under and work with as well.
Dr. Robin: Well, and you learn which ones are better or worse, and how to work with them.
Jill: So, you know. Yeah, that's right.
Dr. Robin: Well, I think we're all out of time here. If you want to be a doctor or something else healthcare-related—probably a nurse after today's conversation—but doctor’s good, doctor’s good. Still be a doctor.
Dr. Robin: Head over to docrobinschool.com/podcast for your goodies. That's D-O-C, Robin like the bird, school dot com.
Jill: Yeah, and don't forget to subscribe so you can hear us chatter on about many more things medical-related in the next episode. And we appreciate each and every one of you for watching, and we'll see you next time. Thanks so much, friends.
Dr. Robin and Jill: Bye, friends. Bye.
